Organizational Compromise of Animal Protection and Welfare Laws

Abstract

The problem investigated in this exploratory study is the welfare of animals, both livestock as well as companion. Specifically, this research explores perceptions by those in the animal industry regarding the support animal welfare, as well as those potentially on the opposite end who handle such issues in their daily business. Animal welfare legal enforcement remains a serious concern, particularly in relation to livestock within major agricultural companies and their confinement and slaughter of those animals. Laws are oftentimes not enforced for various reasons even by appropriate police units and cases are often ignored by the court system. In an attempt to find agreement upon the animal welfare system between animal welfare organizations and their potential business counterparts, a survey was administered to various groups surrounding both sides of the issue. It is hypothesized that if those in the animal industry agree upon anything, it is more likely they would agree on issues surrounding companion animals rather than livestock. Although there has been an abundance of research in relation to animal abuse and its connection to human violence, there have been few studies focusing solely upon animal abuse and welfare, the laws which currently govern such issues, and the varying opinions and potential compromise on those issues. By looking at two main animal categories and attempting to find a compromised ground between animal welfare and pro-business organizations, there can be some level of consensus regarding animal welfare policies, and procedures can be developed in order to properly address identified concerns.